Reviews on your website and Instagram: What the research shows and what tattoo artists are allowed to do
Last reviewed: November 20, 2026. Based on the original reports from the Spiegel Research Center and BrightLocal, the German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG), EU law, and an analysis of around 190 review requests on tatme.com (September to November 2026). Researched and written with AI assistance, reviewed by and under the responsibility of Daniel Menius.
Where do client reviews matter most for tattoo artists?
Where someone decides whether to contact you: on your website, close to the inquiry form. Your Google reviews live on Google. They don't show up on your own website by themselves.
A typical case: someone is clicking through your website late at night, the inquiry form is open, then they close the laptop. Your work convinced them, but nobody tells them: I was there, it went well. Google may show 4.9 stars next to your name, but your page doesn't have a single sentence from a client.
In BrightLocal's Local Consumer Review Survey, 71 percent said they always (29 percent) or regularly (42 percent) read online reviews when browsing for local businesses. 83 percent used Google to do so (BrightLocal 2025, online survey in the US, n = 1,026).
What did the five-review study actually measure?
It measured how often views of the product pages of a single US online store ended in a purchase while the products gradually collected reviews. It has nothing to do with tattoo bookings or Instagram. To do this, Northwestern University's Spiegel Research Center worked with PowerReviews, a review software vendor, and analyzed about 15.5 million page views for 1,800 products from the gift retailer Hammacher Schlemmer (January 4, 2015 to January 2, 2016).
| Finding | Result |
|---|---|
| Product with five reviews compared with a product with none | 270 percent higher purchase likelihood, about 3.7 times |
| Expensive and cheap products (above and below the median price) once they display reviews | up to 380 and up to 190 percent higher purchase likelihood |
| How many reviews it takes | Almost the entire increase comes with the first 10, most of it with the first 5. Expensive products needed at least 5, cheap ones 2 to 4 |
| Average star rating | Purchase likelihood usually peaked at 4.0 to 4.7 stars and dropped again toward 5.0 |
Until November 2026, the title of this article said that five reviews make a booking 4.8 times more likely. That figure was derived from the 380 percent for expensive products, which applies as soon as there are any reviews at all.
Closer to a studio is a BrightLocal survey (North America 2016, n = 6,283): people asked to imagine they were looking for a plumber, a florist, or a realtor said they would contact the business 74 percent of the time after a landing page with a real customer review, and 62 percent of the time without one.
Both sources point in the same direction: reviews help where someone makes a decision, and just a few make the biggest difference.
Why does one sentence often count more than the twentieth photo with a tattoo?
Because a tattoo is a high-risk decision, and in the Spiegel Research Center's data, reviews had the strongest effect on exactly those decisions. As reasons why people deliberate longer, the report names, besides price, health and safety, personal identity, and new products or brands (Spiegel Research Center 2017, p. 8). Almost all of that applies to a tattoo.
A well-healed back piece shows that you know your craft. It doesn't show whether someone with a pounding heart was in good hands with you. A line like "First tattoo, I was scared, and it was more relaxed than I expected" answers exactly that question. First-timers in particular look for lines like that.
Reviews don't replace an explanation of how things work with you. Your process section says what happens. Reviews tell how it felt.
How many clients leave a review when you ask?
On tatme.com, almost one in two: around 190 automatic requests sent after a check-in led to a review 44.8 percent of the time.
Method. After a check-in with the digital consent form, tatme.com asks for a review by email the day after the session and, if none comes in, by text message the next morning. We counted all requests sent from September 28 to November 13, 2026 whose link (valid for 7 days) had expired by November 20, 2026.
Of these reviews, almost two thirds came in within 24 hours of the email, and almost a third only after the text reminder. For artists with at least five requests, the median response rate is 46.2 percent.
Clients rate five questions (consultation, atmosphere, communication, hygiene, tattoo) from 1 to 5. All reviews after a check-in received by November 20, 2026 average 4.94, none gives a 3 or lower, and 77.9 percent include written text.
The limits of this analysis:
- Only check-ins, short period. It only counts clients who checked in with the consent form, over a little more than six weeks, and without a comparison group that got no request.
- Unhappy clients may not write at all. The consistently high ratings fit a finding from the Spiegel Research Center: people who reviewed after an email request gave better ratings on average (4.34 stars) than people who reviewed on their own (3.89 stars) (Spiegel Research Center 2017, p. 14).
What is prohibited when you collect and show reviews?
Fake, bought, and filtered reviews are prohibited in Germany and the EU. Anyone who shows reviews also has to say whether and how they check that the reviews come from real clients. The rules come from the EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC), which Directive (EU) 2019/2161 extended with rules on reviews, and apply in every EU country, in Germany through the Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG). The European Commission's 2021 guidance explains how authorities interpret them (section 4.2.4).
| What | Rule | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Writing reviews yourself, having them written, or buying them | Always prohibited, even when real clients are paid for a positive review | Annex No. 23c UWG, guidance 4.2.4 |
| Publishing only positive reviews and deleting negative ones | Named by the EU as an example of prohibited manipulation of reviews | Annex No. 23c UWG, Recital 49 of Directive (EU) 2019/2161 |
| Asking only happy clients for reviews and getting critics to withdraw theirs, pre-writing positive texts, pushing clients to change a review | Named by the European Commission as examples of manipulation | Guidance 4.2.4 |
| Presenting reviews as coming "from real clients" | Only allowed with reasonable steps to check, such as a booking number or a verified email address | Annex No. 23b UWG, guidance 4.2.4 |
| Showing reviews | You have to state whether and how you make sure they come from people who actually used your service. According to the Commission, this includes whether all reviews are published and how an average is calculated, right where the reviews are shown | Section 5b(3) UWG, guidance 4.2.4 |
| Giving something in return for a review, such as a discount | It has to be clear that there was something in return. The Commission names sponsored reviews without disclosure as unfair | Section 5a(4) UWG, Recital 47 of Directive (EU) 2019/2161, guidance 4.2.4 |
For Google reviews, Google also prohibits incentives such as money, discounts, or free services, and it prohibits selectively asking only happy clients for reviews or discouraging negative ones (Google, Maps user contributed content policy).
In everyday terms: ask everyone, not just the people you have a good feeling about. Don't delete or hide a review just because it's critical. You may, however, remove fake negative reviews (guidance 4.2.4). And put a sentence next to your reviews explaining how they come about, for example: "All reviews come from clients after their appointment with me. Every person confirms their email address. I publish all reviews, including critical ones." Only write what is actually true for you.
This is not a substitute for legal advice on your specific case.
How do you show reviews on your website and Instagram?
On your website, they belong close to the inquiry, together with the sentence about how they come about. On Instagram, they go in a story that you then save to a highlight: a story disappears after 24 hours, a highlight stays on your profile until you remove it (Instagram).
Show all reviews on your website, not just the best ones. The law requires it, and it helps credibility: in online retail, purchase likelihood was usually highest at 4.0 to 4.7 stars and dropped toward 5.0 (Spiegel Research Center 2017, p. 9). A 4 that says "The appointment got moved, but the tattoo turned out really strong" shows that you don't filter.
For your story, you can choose voices that fit your audience, for first-timers, for example, what other first-timers wrote. Only shorten a review in a way that keeps its meaning.
What does tatme take care of?
On tatme.com, the request after a check-in goes out automatically, the review appears on your Artist Page, and you get a finished story image for Instagram.
- Request and reminder: After a check-in with an email address, an email goes out in your name at 10am local time the day after the session, and if no review comes in, a text message to a valid mobile number the next morning. The link is valid for 7 days. You can turn off "Ask automatically" under "Reviews."
- Without a check-in: For other clients, you create a link (valid for 14 days) and send it yourself.
- Verification and display: The person leaving the review confirms their email address with a code. After that, the review appears on your Artist Page, provided the page is public.
- Story: tatme.com turns a review into a portrait story image that you post on Instagram.
You can hide or delete reviews, but the EU explicitly calls removing critical reviews for that reason alone a manipulation (Recital 49 of Directive (EU) 2019/2161).
What can you try this week?
- Reviews close to the inquiry. Put your latest reviews on your website next to the inquiry button.
- One sentence on where they come from. Next to them, write how the reviews come about, the way it actually works for you.
- One highlight. Create a "Reviews" highlight on Instagram and add every new review story to it.
How was this article made?
We checked the Spiegel Research Center and BrightLocal figures against the original reports, and the legal situation against the wording of the UWG, the directive, and the guidance. Our own numbers come from an analysis of review requests on tatme.com dated November 20, 2026. This article was researched and written with AI assistance, and Daniel Menius reviewed it and holds editorial responsibility for it.
How to cite this article
Menius, Daniel (2026): Reviews on your website and Instagram: What the research shows and what tattoo artists are allowed to do. tatme.com, last reviewed November 20, 2026. https://tatme.com/en/wissen/kundenbewertungen-auf-der-website
Every section has a fixed address that doesn't change when the article is updated. For example, you can link directly to the overview of the rules at https://tatme.com/en/wissen/kundenbewertungen-auf-der-website#was-erlaubt-ist.
Changes
- November 20, 2026: Revised, sources checked against the originals, and our own data from tatme.com added.
- September 30, 2026: First published.
Sources
- Spiegel Research Center, Northwestern University (2017): How Online Reviews Influence Sales. Evidence of the Power of Online Reviews to Shape Customer Behavior, report (PDF), overview page: spiegel.medill.northwestern.edu
- PowerReviews and Spiegel Research Center, Northwestern University (n.d., data from January 4, 2015 to January 2, 2016): From Reviews to Revenue, Volume 3: How ratings and reviews impact ecommerce conversion for Hammacher Schlemmer, report (PDF)
- Askalidis, G., Malthouse, E. C. (2016): The Value of Online Customer Reviews. Proceedings of the 10th ACM Conference on Recommender Systems (RecSys 2016), pp. 155 to 158, doi.org/10.1145/2959100.2959181
- Anderson, Myles, BrightLocal (2017): How Online Reviews Impact Trust and Landing Page Conversion, May 12, 2017, brightlocal.com
- Paget, Sammy, BrightLocal (2025): Local Consumer Review Survey 2025, January 29, 2025, brightlocal.com
- German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG): Section 5a, Section 5b, and Annex to Section 3(3) (in German), gesetze-im-internet.de
- Directive (EU) 2019/2161 of November 27, 2019 as regards the better enforcement and modernisation of Union consumer protection rules, OJ L 328, December 18, 2019, p. 7, eur-lex.europa.eu
- European Commission (2021): Guidance on the interpretation and application of Directive 2005/29/EC concerning unfair business-to-consumer commercial practices in the internal market, OJ C 526, December 29, 2021, p. 1, section 4.2.4, eur-lex.europa.eu
- Google: Prohibited & restricted content, Maps user contributed content policy, retrieved November 20, 2026, support.google.com
- Instagram: Instagram Stories, retrieved November 20, 2026, about.instagram.com
- tatme.com: analysis of review requests after a check-in, September to November 2026, as of November 20, 2026. Method in the section "How many clients leave a review when you ask?"